Do you love games where your choices matter? The Quarry is one of the best games for that. It’s like playing a horror movie. You make decisions, and they change the story. Some choices lead to happy endings, while others… not so much.
Many people love The Quarry because it feels real. The characters look like real people, and the story keeps you on the edge of your seat. You decide who lives and who doesn’t. Every playthrough is different, so you can go back and try new choices. Games with deep stories make you feel like part of the action. You don’t just watch—you control what happens. These games mix movies and gaming in a cool way. Instead of just running and shooting, you get to:
- Talk to characters and change their relationships
- Make big choices that change the ending
- Explore creepy places to find clues
- Play again to see different results
Some games focus on adventure, while others lean into horror. But all of them pull you in with strong stories. For a horror game like The Quarry to be great, it needs a few things:
- Tough Choices – You should feel nervous about every decision. One wrong move, and someone might not make it.
- Creepy Setting – The place should feel spooky, like an abandoned house or a dark forest.
- Realistic Characters – They should act and talk like real people. It makes you care about them.
- Surprises Everywhere – Jump scares, unexpected twists, and creepy sounds make the game exciting.
- Replay Value – The best games make you want to go back and try different choices.
If you loved The Quarry, there are plenty of other games that give you the same thrill. Let’s check them out!
What Makes Games Like The Quarry Special?
Some games are fun because of fast action. Others are fun because of deep stories. The Quarry is all about the story—and your choices shape it. These kinds of games pull you in, making you feel like you’re part of a movie. But what makes them so special?
Branching Narratives & Player Choice – How Decisions Impact the Story
In The Quarry, every choice matters. Say the wrong thing? Someone might not trust you later. Take the wrong path? You could walk straight into danger.
These games have branching narratives, which means different choices lead to different results. You might see a happy ending, or you might lose every character. The game reacts to what you do, so no two players get the same experience.
Cinematic Presentation – Realistic Visuals, Voice Acting, and Immersive Storytelling
Games like The Quarry feel like interactive movies. The characters look real, thanks to motion capture technology. The actors give strong performances, making every scene feel alive. The music and camera angles add even more suspense.
Instead of just playing, you watch and feel the story unfold. Every moment, from a quiet conversation to a terrifying chase, looks like it belongs in a big-budget film.
Horror & Suspense Elements – Dark Themes, Jump Scares, and Tension-Building Mechanics
Horror games need suspense—that feeling that something bad is about to happen. Games like The Quarry use:
- Jump scares – Sudden shocks that make your heart race.
- Creepy sounds – A twig snapping, a whisper in the dark, a distant scream.
- Dark themes – Stories about survival, fear, and the unknown.
The best horror games don’t just throw monsters at you. They make you feel uneasy, even in quiet moments.
Replayability & Multiple Endings – Encouraging Multiple Playthroughs
One of the coolest things about The Quarry is that you can play again and get a new story. Maybe the first time, your favorite character didn’t make it. Next time, you make better choices and change their fate.
Many of these games have dozens of endings. Some are happy. Some are tragic. Some reveal secrets you missed before. This makes the game fun to replay, letting you discover new details each time.
If you love games that mix horror, choices, and deep storytelling, you’re in for a treat. Let’s look at some of the best games like The Quarry!
The Best Games Like The Quarry
If you loved The Quarry, you’re in luck! There are plenty of other games with deep stories, tough choices, and thrilling moments. Whether you want more horror, mystery, or emotional drama, these games deliver the same kind of interactive experience.
Let’s dive into the best games like The Quarry and see what makes each one special.
Until Dawn (2015) – The Closest Match
If you’re looking for a game almost identical to The Quarry, Until Dawn is the best pick. It was made by the same studio, Supermassive Games, and has a similar mix of horror, choice-driven storytelling, and multiple endings.
In Until Dawn, you control a group of teenagers who visit a remote cabin in the mountains. Things quickly take a terrifying turn when they realize something is hunting them. Just like The Quarry, your choices decide who lives and who doesn’t. Every decision matters—one mistake, and a character could be gone forever.
The game also uses quick-time events (QTEs), where you have to press buttons quickly to avoid danger. If you miss, you might cause a disaster. The game’s graphics and acting make it feel like a real horror movie, with famous actors like Rami Malek adding to the experience.
If you loved the teen horror movie vibes of The Quarry, Until Dawn should be your next game.
The Dark Pictures Anthology (Series) – Episodic Horror Stories
Supermassive Games didn’t stop after Until Dawn. They created The Dark Pictures Anthology, a series of shorter horror games with the same interactive storytelling.
Each game in this series has its own creepy story:
- Man of Medan – A group of friends on a boat trip finds an abandoned WWII ghost ship.
- Little Hope – A town filled with dark secrets and eerie visions of witches.
- House of Ashes – Soldiers trapped in underground ruins full of terrifying creatures.
- The Devil in Me – A documentary crew stays in a hotel inspired by a real-life serial killer’s murder house.
These games are like The Quarry but in bite-sized form. They still have life-or-death choices, multiple endings, and cinematic storytelling. Each one can be played alone or with friends, making them even more fun.
If you want more horror stories with tough decisions, this series is perfect.
Detroit: Become Human – Futuristic Narrative with Choices
This game is a bit different from The Quarry, but it still has deep branching choices and multiple endings. Instead of horror, Detroit: Become Human takes place in a futuristic world where androids (robots that look like humans) start to think and feel.
You play as three androids, each with their own story. Every choice you make changes their fate. Just like The Quarry, small decisions can lead to huge consequences. Will you be kind or ruthless? Will you start a peaceful revolution or a violent uprising?
The game looks stunning, with realistic graphics and incredible voice acting. While it’s not a horror game, it gives you the same immersive storytelling and moral dilemmas that make The Quarry so gripping.
If you love games that make you think about your choices, give this one a shot.
Life is Strange (Series) – Emotional Storytelling with Supernatural Twists
If you liked the story-driven experience of The Quarry but want less horror and more emotion, Life is Strange is a great pick.
Each game in the Life is Strange series follows a character with a special power, like time travel or mind-reading. Unlike The Quarry, where survival is the main goal, these games focus on friendship, relationships, and personal growth.
Some highlights from the series:
- Life is Strange 1 – Max, a high school student, discovers she can rewind time.
- Life is Strange: Before the Storm – A prequel about Chloe and her struggles.
- Life is Strange 2 – Two brothers on the run after a tragic event.
- Life is Strange: True Colors – Alex, a girl who can feel and change emotions.
While not as scary as The Quarry, these games still make you feel deeply connected to the characters. If you want interactive storytelling with strong emotions, try Life is Strange.
Heavy Rain – A Murder Mystery with Multiple Perspectives
If you enjoy suspenseful stories and multiple perspectives, Heavy Rain is a fantastic choice.
In this game, you play as four different characters, all connected by a serial killer known as the Origami Killer. Each character’s choices affect the story, just like in The Quarry. Some might survive, others might not—it’s all up to you.
Unlike The Quarry, Heavy Rain is more of a detective thriller. Instead of horror, it focuses on mystery, tension, and moral dilemmas. The game’s story is full of twists, and the ending depends entirely on what you do.
If you like dark, emotional storytelling with intense choices, you’ll love Heavy Rain.
The Walking Dead (Telltale Series) – Gritty Survival Storytelling
Zombies? Check. Tough choices? Check. A gripping story? Double check.
Telltale’s The Walking Dead is one of the best choice-driven games ever made. It’s based on the famous comic and TV series, but you don’t need to be a fan to enjoy it.
In this game, you play as different characters trying to survive in a zombie apocalypse. Like The Quarry, every decision matters. Do you help someone, or leave them behind? Do you trust a stranger, or play it safe?
The choices feel real, and the game doesn’t hold back. Characters you love might not make it, and there’s no perfect ending. If you want a game where choices hit hard, this is the one for you.
Oxenfree – Supernatural Thriller with a Unique Dialogue System
Oxenfree is a spooky mystery game with an awesome dialogue system. Instead of picking choices from a menu, you pick dialogue while characters are talking, making conversations feel natural.
The story follows a group of teenagers who visit an abandoned island for fun—until strange things start happening. They accidentally open a portal to a supernatural world, and now they have to figure out how to fix it.
While it’s not as scary as The Quarry, it has the same creepy atmosphere, great characters, and multiple endings. If you like eerie mysteries, Oxenfree is worth playing.
The Inpatient – A VR Horror Prequel to Until Dawn
If you want a first-person horror experience, The Inpatient is a must-try. It’s set in the same world as Until Dawn and tells the story of what happened before that game.
You play as a patient in a creepy asylum, trying to figure out why you’re there. The game uses VR, so it feels like you’re actually inside the story. Every choice matters, just like in The Quarry, and the game reacts to your voice.
If you have a VR headset and love horror, this is one of the most immersive games you can play.
What’s Next for Interactive Story Games?
Interactive story games have become a major part of the gaming world. Players love the way these games let them make choices, shape the story, and experience different endings. As technology improves, these games are getting even better. Let’s take a look at where interactive storytelling is headed and some exciting upcoming games in this genre.
The Rise of Interactive Storytelling in Gaming
Over the years, interactive story games have grown from simple text-based adventures to full cinematic experiences. Games like Until Dawn, The Quarry, and Detroit: Become Human have shown that players love making choices that change the outcome of a story.
A few key reasons why this genre is becoming even more popular:
- Better Technology – Game engines now create more realistic characters, smoother animations, and deeper stories. AI is also improving, making characters react more naturally.
- More Player Freedom – Modern interactive games give players even more choices. Instead of just picking between two or three paths, new games have complex branching narratives where even small decisions change the ending.
- Immersive Experiences – Virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) are making interactive storytelling more engaging. Players can step inside the game world and experience stories firsthand.
- Stronger Narratives – Developers are focusing on writing deep, emotional stories with well-developed characters, making these games feel like interactive movies.
With all these advancements, the future of interactive storytelling looks exciting. Now, let’s take a look at some upcoming or rumored games in this genre.
Upcoming or Rumored Games in This Genre
Several game studios are working on new interactive story games. While some have been officially announced, others are still rumored. Here are a few titles to keep an eye on:
The Casting of Frank Stone
This new horror game from Supermassive Games (the studio behind The Quarry and Until Dawn) is set in the same universe as Dead by Daylight. It promises a chilling interactive experience where every decision matters.
The Expanse: A Telltale Series
Telltale Games is returning with a new game based on The Expanse TV series. Like The Walking Dead games, it will feature deep storytelling and tough moral choices in a sci-fi setting.
Star Wars: Eclipse
Quantic Dream, the studio behind Detroit: Become Human, is working on Star Wars: Eclipse. This game will feature branching choices and a deep narrative set in the Star Wars universe.
Silent Hill: Townfall
Developed by No Code and published by Annapurna Interactive, this psychological horror game aims to bring fresh storytelling to the Silent Hill series.
Life is Strange 5 (Rumored)
The Life is Strange series is known for its emotional, choice-driven stories. While nothing is confirmed yet, there are strong rumors that another game is in development.
The Dark Pictures Anthology: Directive 8020
Supermassive Games has already teased their next Dark Pictures title, Directive 8020. Unlike past games, this one will take place in a sci-fi horror setting, offering a fresh take on their choice-based formula.
Conclusion
If you loved The Quarry, there are plenty of other great interactive story games to check out. Whether you want more horror, deep storytelling, or thrilling choices, there’s something for everyone.
- Until Dawn – The closest match with teen horror and multiple endings.
- The Dark Pictures Anthology – Shorter but packed with decision-based horror stories.
- Detroit: Become Human – A sci-fi take on branching narratives and player choice.
- Life is Strange – Emotional storytelling with supernatural twists.
- Heavy Rain – A gripping murder mystery with multiple perspectives.
- The Walking Dead (Telltale Series) – A survival drama with tough emotional choices.
- Oxenfree – A supernatural thriller with a unique dialogue system.
- The Inpatient – A VR horror prequel to Until Dawn.
Each of these games offers a unique experience, but all of them share what makes The Quarry special—engaging stories, tough decisions, and high replay value.
Interactive games keep getting better, and there’s always something new to try. Whether you enjoy horror, sci-fi, drama, or mystery, these games put you in control of the story. If you love making choices that shape the world around you, don’t stop at The Quarry—explore these amazing alternatives!
What’s your favorite interactive story game? Let us know in the comments!
